MathYouLike MathYouLike
  • Toggle menubar
  • Toggle fullscreen
  • Toggle Search
  •    Sign up
  • QUESTIONS
  • TAGS
  • USERS
  • BADGES
  • UNANSWERD
  • ASK A QUESTION
  • BLOG
...

Carter

10/04/2017 at 08:39
Answers
4
Follow

Let a;b;c be integers such that \(\dfrac{a}{b}+\dfrac{b}{c}+\dfrac{c}{a}=3\). Prove that abc is the cube of an integer.


intergernumber


    List of answers
  • ...
    John 10/04/2017 at 15:24

    Without loss of generality, we may assume gcd(a,b,c) = 1.

    (otherwise, if d=gcd(a,b,c) the for a'=a/d, b'=b/d, c'=c/d, the equation still holds for a', b', c' and a'b'c' is still a cube if only if abc is a cube).

    We multiply equation by abc, we have:

      \(a^2c+b^2a+c^2b=3abc\)(*)

    if \(abc=\pm1\), the problem is solved.

    Otherwise, let p be a prime divisor of abc. Since gcd(a,b,c)=1, the (*) implies that p divides exactly two of a, b,c. By symetry, we may assume p divides a, b but not c. Suppose that the lagest powers of p dividing a, b are m, n, respecively.

    If n < 2m, then \(n+1\le2m\)  and \(p^{n+1}\)| \(a^2c,b^2c,3abc\). Hence \(p^{n+1}\)|\(c^2b\), forcing \(\)\(p\)|\(c\) (a contradiction). If n > 2m, then \(n\ge2m+1\) and \(p^{2m+1}\)|\(c^2b,b^2a,3abc\). Hence \(p^{2m+1}\)|\(a^2c\), forcing \(p\)|\(c\) (a contradicton). Therefore n = 2m and \(abc=\Pi p^{3m}\), \(p\)|\(abc\), is a cube.

    Carter selected this answer.

Post your answer

Please help Carter to solve this problem!



Weekly ranking


© HCEM 10.1.29.225
Crafted with by HCEM